What Do We Do with the Empty Chair?
The whole clan had gathered for Thanksgiving. The women were removing the hot dishes from the oven, placing ice in the cups, setting the “big” table as well as the kids’ table. It was hard to get a head count of all the adults and kiddos. The table was set festively, complete with matching tablecloths and napkins, silverware and serving spoons placed appropriately. No room for centerpieces here – the table was covered with favorite family recipes. Someone called everyone to come and gather around for the prayer. Then as we began to find our places, one of us realized there was an extra place setting. OH NO, we had inadvertently set a place for Pappaw, who had died just a few months prior. MOVE IT QUICK BEFORE NANNY SEES IT! Hurriedly, the extra chair and place setting were removed and the other chairs shuffled to fill in the gap. I don’t know if anyone else in the family remembers this, but I do. And it happened more than 40 years ago.
As a chaplain, if someone had shared this story with me, I would have asked why they didn’t just leave the empty chair and place setting where they were and acknowledge the painful truth that the loved one was not with them physically but would always be in their hearts. And the empty setting would be a beautiful way to memorialize the family’s love for him. Isn’t that an appropriate chaplain response?
But in reality, the emotions of loss can be hard to bear. Especially during the holidays if the family has a long history of the ritual of gathering together.
So this brings up two questions through different lenses. Lens One: how can I provide caring support to my friends who are facing The Empty Chair in the upcoming holidays? Lens Two: what celebratory rituals can my own family create to acknowledge The Empty Chair?
Lens One: Don’t be afraid to mention the obvious. Tell your friend you realize this is their first big holiday without their dear one. Ask about their family traditions and their memories with him/her. These simple inquiries may gently open the door for your friend to share emotions that are bubbling beneath the surface, just needing an opportunity to be spoken. Send a holiday card with a message of “I’m thinking about you.” Just the fact that you have remembered the impact of their loss will be deeply appreciated.
Lens Two: I will address this from a personal perspective. My Dad died last September. Thanksgiving was just around the corner. My sister and I began the conversation early. We openly addressed the elephant in the room. We acknowledged it would be our first Thanksgiving without Dad and wondered out loud how we could keep his memory in our holiday gathering. These were tearful but joyful conversations. It felt good to talk about how much he loved the sweet potato casserole and turkey and Mother’s yeast rolls. We would miss the way he prayed over the meal, his simple words of gratitude, his voice. We would have too many desserts but everyone mentioned Dad when they got a slice of his favorite chocolate meringue pie, lovingly prepared by my sister. And we felt his presence when we all piled up on the couch afterwards, full of food and love, and napped while the football game was on the TV.
Somehow the intentionality of our first Thanksgiving without Dad helped redeem the scenario from 40 years ago.
As the holidays approach us, may we offer comfort to those experiencing The Empty Chair. And may we extend grace to ourselves, acknowledging both the sorrow and joy we feel as we remember those who will continue to live on in our hearts.


